5

I've noticed recently some answers where the author of the answer suggests that the Original Poster contact him/her offsite for further discussion. I'm not sure how I feel about that, myself. On the one hand, it's good to help people, and I suspect we've all met questions where the amount of repeated back-and-forth required to precisely elicit the underlying issue generates an unseemly amount of traffic for a Q&A board. On the other hand, however, a key purpose of this site is to allow answers to be offered in public, where they can both be vetted by the user community, and found by others besides the OP.

Do we, as a community, have any strong feelings about this practice?

2 Answers 2

7

I feel it is not appropriate to suggest in your answer to continue the discussion in private.

On the one hand, the question asker loses the public scrutiny of the answers, which is an important aspect of the sites in the Stack Exchange network. The public scrutiny ensures you get high quality answers.

On the other hand, such an invitation can easily be seen as a request for private consultation (for a fee), which is not really all that different from spam in my view.

1
  • 3
    Taking discussions elsewhere also removes them from the safety of community moderation, but if anything bad were to happen, the victims would likely still feel like they were harmed by this community. Taking discussions to chat here is different, as the mods can still keep a watchful eye on it. Jan 3 at 12:44
3

In some cases, offering further contact can be OK. However, such offers can easily meet the Stack Exchange definition of spam:

  • Is it promoting a product or service? Yes, in the widest sense - regardless of whether there's a profit motive.
  • Is the offer unsolicited or lacks disclosure of affiliation? Yes, the offer is unsolicited. When the contact offer is irrelevant to the subject being discussed, I'd treat it as unsolicited.

(But these answers also tend to contain lots of links that promote a project without disclosing the author's affiliation, which might be a kind of spam by itself.)

I think offering contact can be OK if

  • this is done extremely rarely;
  • the offer is meaningfully related to the question (the offer is helpful); and
  • the ensuing discussion would not be of interest to the community.

For example, a person who wants to start contributing to an open source project asks about community conventions regarding such contributions. The question is not specific to a project, but clearly relates to a particular project. One of the maintainers of that project sees the question, answers it in general, but also offers to walk the asker through the contribution process for that particular project. This should be OK because the offer of contact is helpful and because the specific contribution process would not be of interest to the wider community. The asker had implicitly solicited the contact offer by mentioning a particular project.

If someone would like to solicit contact or promote a project more generally, they can do it on their user profile.

Disclosure: I have previously exchanged contact details on this site, though it was done in a comment thread and not an answer.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .